Add a comment
You must be logged in to be able to post comments!
Create my account Sign in
Top comments
  MissBoo101  |  0

I don't think it's that bad I mean if she just puts in on then realizes what it is I think it's kind of cute I mean if when she realizes what it is and they both hug and stuff I think its cute

  pink_raindrops  |  26

Him throwing the ring at her and saying "Here, wear this" is far from cute. I'm not one who think the guy needs to go all out or be super romantic when they propose, but you definately shouldn't just toss it at her and expect her to tear up with joy. I would toss it right back at him and not get engaged to him for a while after that, if ever. It just seems like a "here's your ring now shut up" kinda moment to me.

  kairi1016  |  0

that's what I thought. To me, "romantic" is simple, and funny. a guy would never win me over with a sterotypical romantic dinner and an on the knee proposal.

  Iskaria  |  0

Better than being proposed to with a joke :P

Here is how my proposal went:

him: You know the way we were talking about maybe getting married some day?
me: Yea?
him: And you said "no ring no answer"
me: Yea, but you know I was kidding.
him: Okay, well, how about this ring? [brings out box, opens it, inside is a napkin ring, the type that look like comically large engagement rings for engagement parties]
me: Oh you're so funny, haha! You ass!
him: Okay, okay, what about this one then? [gets out proper ring]
me: Wha-?

  goshpeople  |  4

The OP presumably would've known that her boyfriend wasn't the romantic-gestures type. I find his approach delightfully unconventional, though, and much more of a "surprise proposal" than getting down on one knee -- making it romantic in its own way.

  Yodaevil  |  4

gotta be careful about selling engagement rings, in some cases the man is entitled to the ring back if the wedding is called off. if the ring was sold (and normally for less than
face value) you can be in trouble. no need op to jump the gun and end up in a worse of position than she is.