FML for mobile
Free

Open in app
FMyLife
Anonymous United States

Today, my dad spent a full half hour trying to convince me that Judaism is a race. FML

Collection

Wild Nights Out

Last call, bad decisions and 3 a.m. texts you'll regret until noon. Cheers.

Same thing different taste

Next

Top comments

Elenachka 0

a lot of people seem to think that

Can't Judaism be a religion and a race? **** me if I'm wrong.

Add a comment · Reply to

You must be logged in to be able to post comments!

Comments (48)

He probably thinks that from Hitler who thought it was a race.

Then Hitler was super racist then

I'm pretty sure Hitler was worse than a super racist

your dad sounds like he is just a bit confused on what its called, but his argument isnt totally without validity. kind of...

Well.... they are a large group of people with a similar belief originating from a similar area of the world. I know that doesn't qualify as a "race" but it could be close enough for your dad.

samyslamajamma 0

Jew is a race and a religion, the too sperate. They can be jewish but not a Jew. And vice versa

so it's not a race?

Well it is a practice for religion, so I doubt its a race.

It's a religion AND an ethnicity. If the 2 didnt happen to share the same name, these ridiculous debate wouldnt happen

um being Jewish is both a religious designation and an ethnicity. it depends on how people identify themselves, and historically how they have been identified by their home countries' governments. also the existence of Israel makes things more complex.

I am Jewish and I can easily say we aren't a race it's a religion

flawedgenius 6

OK. initially I'm gonna have to call you a dumbass until you explain this [ also the existence of Israel makes things more complex. ] at the end of your reply. WTF is that all about? Some people are so ignorant these days, it would be funny if it wasn't so sad... ~S

wrong Its both you don't have to be a practicing Jew but you can still be of Jewish decent. if you trace it back Judaism was the belief of the Jewish people Jewish being the people and Judaism the religion kthnxbai

well it is actually an ethnicity, so he's almost right.

Blacksmokehick 0

burn the ******* gays

Out of any bad FML ever on this site, I hope this one gets deleted. This will start a huge, misinformed, infuriating argument. Not to mention it's very existence shows how misinformed the moderators are all well. Oh, and google it for gods sake. Judaism is a religion, BUT Jews are a race as well. I am not of any religion, but because I have Jewish blood, am part Ashkenazi Jew as well as part Celtic. Those are my ETHNICITIES and one can be separate from another.