211
By NoSpirit - / Thursday 1 November 2012 08:20 /
Add a comment
You must be logged in to be able to post comments!
Create my account Sign in
Top comments
Comments
Reply

If they're in America, the lady may have a case. I still don't understand how that old lady won a lawsuit against McDonalds for spilling hot coffee on HERSELF! ..

Reply

Too many negative votes, comment buried. Show the comment

Reply

She could sue for "emotional distress", although that's the point of Halloween, so the judge might just laugh in her face. And yes 31, the coffee was hotter than it was supposed to be. What the media didn't tell anyone is that that particulate McDonalds was told multiple times that their coffee was too hot, and that just proved it.

Reply

Too many negative votes, comment buried. Show the comment

Reply

She also had to get skin grafts for her third degree burns on her lap, and therefore on her genitals. So yes, she had every right to sue.

Reply

36 - Also the land where someone can sue McDonald's, Burger King and KFC for making them fat. Regardless of the fact that they ate there 3 times a day, everyday.

Reply

26 - At that time, McDonald's kept their coffee above boiling temperature - above 212 degrees Fahrenheit. This was so they could pour several cups in advance of being ordered and they wouldn't cool off too much that customers complained. McDonald's had been warned over a dozen times to lower the temperature of their coffee. Finally, a woman sued when she received 3rd degree burns (which burns away all of your layers of skin, down to the muscle) when she spilled a cup of coffee from McDonald's

Reply

Too many negative votes, comment buried. Show the comment

Reply

Too many negative votes, comment buried. Show the comment

Reply

Too many negative votes, comment buried. Show the comment

Reply

Too many negative votes, comment buried. Show the comment

Reply

Too many negative votes, comment buried. Show the comment

Reply

Too many negative votes, comment buried. Show the comment

Reply

Actually, the McDonalds held coffee at 180 degrees which would cause 3rd degree burns in something like 5 seconds of contact. She also took the lid off of the coffee in the car. I don't think she deserved all the money she got as she was being negligible at the time.

Reply

As I understand it, her insurance company made her sue, and the coffee was indeed hotter than it should've been. Still stupid, though.

Reply

They're on your property and it is their word against yours. They have no case, you'll be fine. The DA would not even consider bringing it to court.

Reply

There was a lawsuit in apex, nc against a Burger King that put cups of hot coffee in paper bags to pass to you through the drive thru window. They would never warn you which bag had your food and which had your coffee. A man sued because the coffee leaked, causing the bag to tear and dump hot coffee in his lap while he was wearing shorts.

Reply

105 - it doesn't matter if they are on his property. Haven't you heard of the burglar who sued the owner of the house he was breaking into because he got hurt in the process? The case would be dismissed based on freedom of speech. The owner can answer his door and say whatever he wants. It just so happened that his word and tone of voice frightened the small child.

Reply

Too many negative votes, comment buried. Show the comment

Reply

68, these "incompetent employees" can't put sleeves that don't exist! The issue was that hot beverage containers didn't come with a "Caution Hot!" warning label on them cause companies foolishly thought that people would use their common knowledge and figure out that their coffee is going to burn them no matter how hot it is! Yes, it might have been too hot however she could have avoided it easily if she was using her brain and didn't place a hot coffee between her legs while

Reply

The only thing that case taught me was if someone gets hurt while braking into your house make sure and finish the job and put a bullet in them so they can't sue

Reply

#115- "Haven't you heard of the burglar who sued the owner of the house he was breaking into because he got hurt in the process?" Yeah, funnily enough I have heard of that... in the movie Liar Liar. How about basing your examples off events that actually happened, not stuff you saw in a comedy movie?

Reply

She probably didn't have a cupholder in her car so she put the coffee between her legs. I don't have a cupholder in my car, so that's where I keep my drinks. I've never burned myself though lol

Reply

138, 120's comment was from that movie. My statement was based off a true case of a guy climbing through a broken window and cutting a major artery in his leg and suing the home owner for the coat of the medical bills.

Reply

"emotional distress" the tort being "Intentional infliction of emotional distress" requires Intentional or reckless act, Extreme and outrageous conduct, Causation (defendant must have actually caused the distress), and actual provable distress,( typically in the form of a mental illness diagnosed after the event) intentionally startling a trick or treater on halloween meets none of the criteria. there is no case not even a whiff of a case. if sued OP could countersue for

Reply

Lots of noise here... 1) If you live ANYWHERE in ANY COUNTRY with a common law system, you CAN sue anyone else for anything you like. How this plays out depends on which country you're in, and in some places you can be punished for filing ridiculous lawsuits, but you are still fully capable of filing them in the first place. 2) If you file a lawsuit against someone, there is NO DISTRICT ATTOURNEY INVOLVED. In the McDonalds matter and the OP's case, these would be CIVIL cases, NOT CRIMINAL ca

Reply

U can sue for anything pretty much I saw a girl sue a guy because he didnt show up for her prom date..

Reply

In order to win a case for emotional distress you have to prove it. Her son would have to go to therapy and seek help for his "emotional distress". I don't think she'd win lol

Reply

To 26: Actually if you look up the facts on that case she had good cause. They were shoving the food out the window so fast that she quickly set the coffee between her legs and when she turned the lid popped off and the coffee was so hot that it melted her sweatpants to her legs and they had to surgically remove it and then graft skin from her backside and the backs of her legs. She was an 79 year old woman. At first she contacted McDonald's and told them that since she believed that they were p

Reply

Krajjan- heres a quick lesson for you DON'T ever put ANYTHING that has the potential to cause harm near ur genitals. Why would u put a knife no matter how dull there anyway?

Reply

On the topic of the McDonald's lawsuit... Google photos of "Stella Liebeck burns" (the woman with the coffee lawsuit). Instant nightmare.

Reply

Oh for gods sake. What is it with people threatening to sue all the time. It's life. Frickin deal with it. If your kid ain't able to deal with a bit of FUN then he's wrapped in too much cotton wool and bubble wrap. That mom needs to cut the umbilical cord!

Reply

Also one big thing everyone is missing... She sued and won like a million or two BUT she only asked for 10k to cover the medical fees.

Reply

Suing over not showing for the prom is a matter of money spent in preparation for the event. If he agreed to take her to this event and he didn't show, for any reason beyond anything unavoidable (accident, death), she may feel entitled to compensation for all that was spent that otherwise would not have been spent (dress, shoes) and could not be used again (hair, makeup). While I think the idea of suing over this is frivolous, and that the expenses are solely on her (because nothing says she HA

Reply

I think he only has the right to take the ring back if she broke up with him. If he breaks up with her then I think it is her right to keep the ring if she chooses because it was in fact a gift to her. It may be an expensive gift, but a gift non the less, and no one has the right to demand to be given back something that they gave of their own free will.

Reply

I used to have to keep my drinks between my legs because of my broken cup holder. I spilled soda on my crotch a few times making it look like I pissed myself. Luckily, I was never a big coffee fan.

Reply

Well 26 that coffee was over 100 degrees hotter than coffee made in a home coffee maker usually is and also she had to get very expensive skin grafts for her 3rd degree burns.

Reply

26, the amount awarded in that case was overturned. She only ended up with her medical bills paid and payment for lost time at work. People always remember the original verdict but never follow to see if it is final.

Reply

How are you going to sue someone for that on any day?! The fucking brat pissed her off, the mother didn't do anything to make it behave. The brat pissed itself. Shit happens, fucking deal with it. They had it coming. You americans somehow like suing eachother don't you?

Reply

They can threaten all they want but yelling "boo" on her own property on Halloween isn't going to get her in trouble. If anything OP could counter sue for slander.

Reply

It was because there wasn't any warning that it may be hot. She also received 3rd degree burns from it too.

Reply

A lot of you are being really insensitive and ignorant. The media and McDonald's purposely made the case look frivolous. The coffee was made over 100° F hotter than it should have been, for one. They were in a parked car and it spilled. It literally fused her labia together and she had to get skin grafts on her thighs, vagina, and her bottom. She was a 79 year old woman. McDonald's was completely at fault. They ignored the many times people have been burned until a woman literally got third degr

Reply

That's what I was thinking. If I had a kid who wanted to act like a brat, I'd let them deal with the consequences. Live & learn!

Reply

Well, the kid that got boo'd wasn't necessarily the kid that rang the doorbell excessively. Though I agree that trying to sue over something like that is a bit crazy.

Too many negative votes, comment buried. Show the comment

Reply

Too many negative votes, comment buried. Show the comment

Reply

3 - Revenge is a dish best served lol'd. The best way to get someone back is to amuse yourself, and scaring people is funny, imo.

Reply

I'm with OP. Some kid knocked on our door for 10 minutes just to "scare" us. It gets annoying. If he were very young I'd feel bad he cried, but some older kids. Hmph.

Too many negative votes, comment buried. Show the comment

Reply

There's no way OP would actually get sued. Boo is a pretty common Halloween thing too yell or shout or to try to startle someone.

Reply

cause ya asked..i went to..GOOGLE! so here is CILD: Centro Italiano Logoterapia Dinamica, Center for Computational Intelligence, Learning and Discovery, Chakra Induced Lucid Dream, Chronic Inactive Liver Disease, Chronic Infiltrative Lung Disease. Not funny? How about: Chest Inducing Lung Destroyer? or Clone Idiots Little Dick.. (ke ke ke..)

sorry, but this fml just cracked me up. Little bugger got what he deserved, and the mom needs to take the stick out of her ass. Oh sure kid is gonna be scared for a couple of days..maybe..but one: it was halloween, and two: did you video tape it? Would be epic to see on youtube. XD

People like you are what made trick or treating fun for me. Sadly, some people just can't take a trick.

Loading data…