how can you not know?

I don't think he thought much of it, normally telling someones gender is a simple task.

I looked him up. He doesn't look girly at all and had a beard in 99% of his pictures.:P

How do you even know who to look up?

I bet it was Black Veil Brides

#49, women can have beards too. And there probably is a man who likes that. But yeah, most of the time that is one of the things how you can see it's a man.

So he can't still be good looking?

Not if it's Marilyn Manson

don't knock marilyn manson. have you seen the women he gets ? I find him to be sexy in a mysterious, creepy kinda way. aaahhhh hell I'd hit it!

But not if you were a guy as op is

What band is it?

I bet it's Against me! The signer Tom Gable became Laura Jane Grace....

Marilyn Manson

Taylor Hanson

Well the singer from against me isn't exactly a beautiful woman now..

Probably Tokio Hotel.

I looked up Tokio Hotel, and must admit they/he are a good contender. But he definitively has a masculine tone to his voice. So how much of a favorite band are they to OP that he deceived him with both looks and vocal tone...

Malice Mizer , Versailles. Etc. jrock bands are full of bishonen and femboys. I wholly appreciate it too from an artistic perspective.

Sleeping with sirens?

Kellin Quinn does and looked like a girl when I heard them at first..

One Direction.

*Lowers sunglasses*... The Barenaked Ladies.

Probably yohio!

It could be Sleeping With Sirens, or Pierce The Veil. The singers do look like girls and they have really high, screechy voices so..

Alice Cooper?

yeahh when I first read this the first thing that popped in my head was Kellin Quinn. whether he looks like a man or woman he is an angel

Could be against me!, saw them live and I really didn't know if it was a woman or dude..

fuck you, man.

Are you sure it's not a pretty woman with manly features

I'm pretty sure it's a "pretty" man with feminine features, hence the confusion..

Better put away the lotion there, OP...

How did you find out?

Im with #4 Is it a very popular band.. People need to know to look out for these minor details. I do wonder how you know these things.. Or are u just a very good groupie ??

I'd say its the dude from rise against. But he's not a very attractive "woman"

How do you mistake Tim McIIrath for a woman at all?

22- Are you sure you don't mean Against Me?

Tokio hotel?

I don't know about you, but I knew Bill was a boy right away

the exact comment I was looking for, I can't think of any other bands with a girly guy lead singer. I remember tricking a couple homophobic friends of mine telling them about this "girl lead singer in a new band" they totally fell for it :)

Or kaya. A lot of V kei bands have really beautiful guys, who dress like girls, as lead singers.

9, that was my first thought too. Bill does look very feminine.

I don't even listen to this band, I've only seen them on TV, like award shows and stuff, but I definitely thought their singer was a girl.

When I first saw a Tokio Hotel videoclip, I thought the singer was an ugly girl (I didn't find "her" attractive). When they told me "she" was a guy named Bill, I was really surprised, and I laughed a lot about it.

#58 I'm not sure the comment about attractiveness was necessary, but I agree the bill is very feminine looking.

We all have had these situations where we can't tell if someone is a boy or girl. But we figure it out 2 mins later

This reminds me of a friend who heard Michael Paynter singing one day, and said "she has the voice of an angel!" Needless to say, he was extremely disappointed to find out it was a dude.

so??

How do you not see the issue?

wow 11 thats just wow