@19 - Your comment reminded me of the Malcolm in the Middle episode where the boys find out they actually have shittier stuff than people donate to charity. I wonder if there's a grain of truth to that episode, and in reality orphans actually get really nice "used" stuff.

I was going to post what you said #1 like word for word and then I clicked on comments and you had already thought of it.

Damn, tough luck #2. Same comment at the same time but #1 got all the glory.

#3 is right, honest mistake! If you want a good conscience maybe put some toys in tomorrow :)

Hahaha love that movie.

Maybe there was only a sign on the opposite side

Emphasis on "normally". In this case there may not have been. At my job there's donation boxes and no signs and people constantly mistake them for trash cans.

I've personally done it. It was a gum wrapper I then fetched out with a bright red face.