Well it depends how close they were, but as soon a they broke up he should have gotten back right away and if he couldn't then change the locks

I don't think so #19, it looks to me like OP's boyfriend had just forgotten she still had one. Otherwise it would be a bit weird to assume that it was her who left it, there's no mention of a note or anything. Honestly OP seems a bit paranoid assuming she stole something. She probably just stopped by to return it and left it on the counter because nobody was home.

Hindsight is 20/20. During their breakup he obviously forgot to get the key back.

Dude, I think it's time you stop trying to comment xD

I agree but at the same time if he's been with op long enough to be living with her than it's far too late for the ex girlfriend to just let herself in to give back the key!

Not necessarily true. My boyfriend broke up with his ex and we moved into a new apartment. We noticed that we had a piece of furniture that had belonged to her and didn't want to take it so we told her to come by and pick it up. She had the keys still and returned them when she came to get her things. It's a bit annoying having her shit in my home but they were living together for years. You think you got rid of everything but some times there's still some things hiding around that you don't even realize. And she didn't return the key after the broke up cause we were moving out anyway

Your bf never changed the locks? For all you know his ex's bf or friend could have a key too...

The awkward moment when you find out your boyfriend is cheating on you with your ex

THAT. If I lived with someone then we broke up, the first thing I would do would be to change the locks. You don't just "Forget" who has access to your HOME. That trashy ho still had a key because he's probably still banging her. Sorry OP.

Dat assumption ^^^^^^^^

Yup, shady. Could have easily mailed it. As it's probably been quite some time since the breakup (I hope) because you're now living together, she may have just found it cleaning the keychain, other option is not good. Time to change locks.

It may be time to change the locks, OP. Especially if there's a possibility that other people may have a key.

Eh. She probably dropped it off while running errands. You weren't there, so she put it inside so it wouldn't get stolen.

Maybe she didn't want to return it while they were home. Not saying it's a good idea, but she probably wanted to avoid an awkward conversation. Doesn't mean she took anything. On the other hand. Maybe there is a reason that OP jumped to this conclusion...

But #57 she could have easily slid the key underneath the door. Or through the mail slot (if the door had one of those).

Get ready, here it comes... What if... OP and the ex didn't have a particularly bad breakup. I'm still really good friends with my ex and would trust her with my life, let alone my house keys. It could be the same situation, no big deal, really. But, they do seem paranoid of theft, so it actually probably is not lol. But oh well

way to stir the pot!

What? 3 spooky 5 me? What does that mean?

2spooky4me??? = too creepy for me?

Maybe there was a reason why he broke up with her.

*holes My bad for not catching that. Sorry

"And always assume someone who came into your house without your permission is crazy, until proven otherwise." YES YES YES on all of it, especially the above. That was a creepy dirty thing for her to do, and thinking about it further, it's probably a power play to remind the new girlfriend that the ex ho bag is still around. She could have done anything to return the key, but she chose to walk right in and probably got really nosy about the guy and his new woman.