Yeah, seriously. You should tell your sister what was in the works. Problem solved.

What a selfish bitch. I mean really. You dump a guy just because he won't propose to you? What the ****? Hey you stupid twat, maybe YOU could propose to HIM instead!! OMG what a concept.

geniusman calm the **** down. the OP's sister dumped the boyfriend, because she thought she wasn't ready for a commitment. Now 4 years into a relationship isn't that bad, but maybe she just really wanted to get married. Now the boyfriend should have seized that opportunity to propose, unless the OPs sister dumped him online or through text or on the phone or something. Or why didn't the OP just tell her that he was going to propose? Either way the OP's life isn't ******. It wasn't even about her except for the fact that she helped.

Hm. She wasn't ready for commitment, yet "she really wanted to get married"? Genius man is right, if she wanted to get married so bad, she could have either proposed herself (why the hell not?) or had a talk with her bf (of 4 years!) about it. Wow. What a ridiculous reason to break off a 4-year relationship.

whoops typo I meant "he wasn't ready for a commitment"

it could hav been worse.... u coulda gotten dumped by ur boyfriend but wat a selfish bitch

I was dumped by my ex husband over the phone, I never got a face to face! Imagine how that feels? Better before than after I say!!

true she might get back with him

Your sisters a bitch!

She didn't know he was going to propose. She had the right to break it off if she wanted to move on and actually get married.

He just wasted 2 whole months?

He just wasted 2 whole months?

Uh, I don't know the culture or relationship standards of where you're from, but it's a little unusual for someone to start proposing, or planning on proposing after the first few dates let alone the first year

She was impatient to be asked. One would think that if she wanted to marry him that she could have taken the non-traditional role of asking him to marry HER! What a concept.

#145 I've been with my GF for 12 years.

@145... Aaaand that's why divorce rates are so high.

And here's a more elaborate proposal. You beat the shit out of her, really lay into her and then say "Now, would you like to do this with me on a semi regular basis?" And while riding back on the ambulance produce the ring from the paramedics pocket. How sweet.

I'll give you that your technique is more creative than mine. Mine has two things going for it: 1) It works in reality -- for me, it is one-for-one. 2) It has a less awkward "out" if the answer is "no." For me, I'd just get up, keep my ring and leave. You'd probably end up in jail with a ring. You might end up with a boyfriend or six.

I like what you did with the jail and ring pun.