Yep. He's a manly man.

Joking? If he's been a good example in the past, then one thing shouldn't change your mind.

I got so much swag yolo ;)

#7 that comment is stupid. What if that one thing reveals a horrible personality flaw, motivation, opinion or past action. I would think revealing that hes an ex member of kkk would be a turn off

You refuted his one example, but his point still stands. Fine, what if you found out that he's a current member of the KKK? (As far as it being a turn off, though; I don't think you should be turned on by your father in law in the first place...)

I wouldn't take that comment personally, he probably just said that because he didn't want to get emotional and feel awkward or he was probably just joking.

Someone pissed in his Cheerios

That's in-laws for ya!

False, his father in law eats only nails for breakfast and instead of milk he uses the tears from his in-laws!

In-laws are so much fun, aren't they? At least you were being honest, even if he doesn't think so.

Or the father knows himself, and OP was just sucking up to him

Don't worry OP, he really appreciates it, but maybe he's too shy to actually share his actual emotions? Good thought, though. :)

And the father of the year award goes to....

Just stop. That "_____ of the year goes to..." is so old.

Asshole-in-law.

Two face.

how?

the expression. To OP, he was one thing, but later showed his other side.

If he is a great example then maybe this shouldn't be too much of a problem ?

And THAT'S why you love him. He's so frank yet charming. :)

Some people have trouble dealing with strong emotion, or put on a tough face by cursing. I'm sure he's honored.