That's a little awkward.. but at the same time, she loved your gift so that's good!

Fuck! It’s getting worse, not better!!! Just when we think the end of the Christmas 2018 stories, we have to dredge up Christmas 2016 stories?!?! How far will this go? Today, I had to give birth in a manger, while three, weird foreign dudes looked at my hoo-hah. FML.

Was it Amnesia?

good things do come back don't they?!..

Well at least you know she liked it.. 2 years later..

I don't find this all that surprising. I often have games that I get one way or another and then don't get to play for months or years until I finally get to them. Sometimes you just need to be in the mood for a game to begin and enjoy. At least you know you gave her something she enjoys.

To be fair, I have Blu-rays and games I received for Christmas many years ago, that are unwatched/unplayed not because I'm ungrateful, but because I just haven't found the time. It could be that this was the same, but with the time that had passed, she forgot who specifically gave it to her. At least she's really enjoying your present OP, even if it is later than you expected.

I'd like to imagine the OP gave her friend the present, and then NEVER EVER EVER EVER asked about it, if she enjoyed it, or what she thought of it, until now, just to post this FML.

had a similar thing happen to me once too,