Replace drywall?? A little spackle and a little paint will fix the issue.

Quit whining, #23. Better comments could have been posted other than that.

For OP that might seem like too much effort and commitment, just like a relationship

Shit. Chew some gum and shove it in the hole and paint over it.

Would they change their mind or not make up their mind?

I think it's already causing life problems. It's nothing to get too hung up on though OP. If you get some professional help they will help you to see the big picture and nail the problem once and for all.

#31 I think you tried a little too hard on that pun.....

Mindception

My roommate put those up so she wouldn't put holes in the wall. When it came time to clean up and move out, she tore them off. And they brought big chunks of paint off the wall with them.

Don't tell OP

You have to pull them straight down. If there is even a little bit of an angle, they will remove paint. It is easier (and rather soothing) to just spackle the holes.

Nice job assuming their gender. Lol.

we're all a little crazy somewhere deep inside.

Heeeyyy might that be a paramore reference?