Today, my boyfriend and I got in a fight about which is better: Star Wars or Lord of the Rings. We aren't speaking. FML
amburrjade
Austin, United States
amburrjade tells us more.
amburrjade 28
Hi guys! I'm the OP :) I'm 19, and my boyfriend's 20. I thought LotR was better, personally. To be fair, I've only seen one of the Star Wars movies, and he's only seen half of one of the LotR movies, so we were both a little biased. This was last night though, and by the morning, it was forgotten. We're all good now. Thanks for your comments! :)
Collection
Black Friday
70% off something you didn't need, a stampede and a cart that crashes at checkout. Thanks, Black Friday.
Top comments
rshweky 17
That's a very serious argument.
swag_bear 18
Uhh lord of he rings all the way!
Add a comment · Reply to
You must be logged in to be able to post comments!
Comments (300)
AhoyCaptian 16
same. I think both are amazing, although it is hard to compare two totally different stories. but I love Lord of the Rings.
malysev 0
There is only one "Return" and it's of the King, not the Jedi.
bratty_sub 4
BTW it's LOTR ;)
abadoo123 15
Am I the only one thinking these two are just childish?
amburrjade 28
Hi guys! I'm the OP :) I'm 19, and my boyfriend's 20. I thought LotR was better, personally. To be fair, I've only seen one of the Star Wars movies, and he's only seen half of one of the LotR movies, so we were both a little biased. This was last night though, and by the morning, it was forgotten. We're all good now. Thanks for your comments! :)
Fatavious 5
BLASPHEMY!!BLASPHEMY!! YOU BOTH SICKEN ME! SMH
sturschaedel 27
Yeah, I'm camp LOTR too. But I haven't seen the movies (and don't even want to see them), but absolutely love the books! They are magical.
livinginabook 24
Keep fighting the good fight OP. LotR is amazing!
BurgundyInk13 9
I'm glad you're on better terms now. And I completely agree with you. My dog's name is Pippin, and it suits him perfectly. I guess I might be a little biased.
jbuckets_404 39
Reduxed Battlestar Galactica tv series is by far, far better than both....
ZelmaSlayer 30
As someone who's seen both series several times, I think the best one was
oops6663 26
Star Wars is fantastic.....but Lord of the Rings totally owns!!!! (also 9/22 was Hobbit Day!)
missmum2010 17
DOCTOR WHO FOR THE WIN!!!
BlackHawkSavior 28
Love Lord of The Rings and Star Wars, you should really watch the movies together and see why the other might like another one. They're both great movies
amburrjade 28
We have plans to sit down and watch both of the series together, but we're probably still gonna be biased as he grew up with Star Wars, and I grew up with LotR, which we've both accepted :)
sprints54 19
Umm no Star Wars is infinitely better than lotr. Way more stories and background and is currently expanding everyday
violetjai 9
One does not simply disagree that LOTR is better.
pandalover69 26
@257 Actually you're wrong about the back story. Have you ever heard of the Salamurian (probably spelled that wrong) or the Hobbit? Both of those explain the world of Lord of the Rings. The first one I mentioned is basically a lotr bible. Star wars is great but it wouldn't even exist if it wasn't for lotr.
xXDemonWolfXx 13
Star Wars came out first the **** are you smoking?
Arwen_Evenstar 37
The LotR books were far before Star Wars. The Hobbit was 1937, LotR was 1954, Star Wars Episode IV was 1977. Also LotR wins.
SilentCat 22
@269 ...do you mean "The Silmarillion"?... If you know it's "the LoTR bible" how can you not know the correct name :(
countryguy91290 16
Hey OP you do realise they are 2 seperate genres, styles, and ere's. It's like comparing bacon to strawberries. I myself grew up on starwars as a kid, lotr didn't become popular till '04 at the release of 2 towers i believe. Were starwars came out in the 80s.
jojocircus19 16
I'm so torn........ I love both!!!
jelrid 30
By sheer mass of information and creativity, yes. But, Star Wars will always be MY favorite! <3
Fatavious 5
the LOTR movies are ******* boring, it's nothing but walking. hell even the trees walked in those movies.
Arwen_Evenstar 37
Yep. Well, asides from the Horse riding, Eagle riding, battle scenes etc.
Geek_Freak 13
Geeks!! These should be the problems of all relationship
sandycheeks99 5
You're both idiots.
SG44 14
Hopefully it gets resolved and whoever said Lord of the Rings is better sees that it's actually Star Wars, best of luck.
vailyn 1
"Only a Sith deals in absolutes"