Way to go OP!!

I guess that just isn't his cup of tea. Everyone is different :)

What a confidence booster

I feel like there's a difference between being vocal and making animal sounds

Wait, were you moaning or mooing?

Rephrased: OP, you're not naturally vocal. You believed that bedroom vocalizations are a turn on for your boyfriend. So you put on a performance intended for his benefit. Would you say that's accurate? Thing is, non-natural vocalizing is the equivalent of faking it. Personally there's no bigger turn off than when a partner fakes it. The way he said "that's a turn off please just behave the way you do naturally because I so dig that" is a whole other story, cause dude was being a dick with that one. Have a chat with him about being respectfull during sexy times or kick his ass to the curb, unless you enjoy being denigrated.

Your boyfriend sounds like a gigantic asshole.

Lmfao! Reminds me of a time when an Austrian guy I was dating a few years ago, decided to speak German during an intimate time, to be sexy. I responded "Can you not, please." Lol

Once I was asked to talk dirty in bed. I panicked and said, "You piece of shit, I wanna fart all over your ****." She got up, put on flannel pajamas and we played parcheesi till the sun came up.

OMG!! Snot came out my nose as I read this and tried not to laugh...