Comments
....Wait, why would you get a cup of water for someone choking...(I will resist trying to say that number. Although I'm prob too late lol)
It's not your fault. He should of said "My daughter's choking!" or something. I would call the guy a jackass if he just cut in front of me.
...is water going to magically help him perform the Heimlich?
Parents should have to take first aid classes.
yeah i dont really see how water is supposed to help someone who is choking, but you still shouldnt assume that he was being a douche.
You're so observant of your surroundings. Way to note what was going on around you. Maybe next time you see a frantic man needing water, you'll take a good hard look around you before you assume he's a jackass.
The only jackass on that beach was you.
#7 - On 04/19/2009 at 7:55pm by uhhuh_her
total YDI. think before you say stuff?
if some guy is frantically asking for water, chances are he probably needs it for a good reason...dont be so quick to assume/judge people
#9 - On 04/19/2009 at 7:57pm by charlottex33
I agree with number 1. She is obviously not choking, because you never give a choking person food/water. but number 9 is also right
This is F the daughter's life.
Today I was at the beach eating a hot dog and I started choking. My father panicked. He ran away, and I assumed that he was going to find someone to help. He comes back with a cup filled with water. I died of asphyxiation. FML.
meh, how were you to know?
11 - post wouldn't exist if shes not alive
Not your fault. He should've said something but at the same time, I'm sure he wasn't really thinking about courtesy at that moment.
Chocking = water?
what? that guy is dumb, and i would have done the same thing, he didn't say what he was doing first, anyone would call him a jackass if he didn't say anything.
it's people like you that give us a bad reputation on the beach. jack to the ass. some people are so thick
that wasn't your problem.
of course if there was someone ahead of you in line, and they had no problem with it, then it is.
But maybe they saw the choking child.
Which, there's a whole ocean... there's water.
I'm not going to think too much into this one, as #4 already stated the biggest question in this FML.
what do you mean theres a whole ocean, theres water?
youre not supposed to drink salt water... which is what the ocean is made of....
smh
#12, it is a joke.
Why are people so stupid? Obviously #11 isn't so dumb to think that little kid's are gonna post FMLs from six feet under. So why do people call out obvious jokes?
Some people just need to be sterilized.
#17 - On 04/19/2009 at 8:03pm by officerpat
jesus, dude. calm down.
#19 - On 04/19/2009 at 8:11pm by mf
Why didn't he do the heimlich?
It doesn't sound that ridiculous, if you have food or water go down wrong it really isn't call for the Heimlich Maneuver and honestly drinking something afterward gets rid of the scratchiness. Definitely an oops moment on your part freaking out on him, but honestly unless his daughter was really young he could have done better in the situation too. I'll give you the FML
why would he need water for a choking person?
i would have thought the same thing. plus you said he "demanded" water not he "frantically asked for a cup of water"
She probably wasn't choking in the sense that she had an object blocking her airways. She probably accidentally got water in her airways - sea water or her own saliva. It's happened to everyone before when you swallow some liquid the wrong way and you end up choking. In that situation, drinking something DOES help.
#27 - On 04/19/2009 at 8:28pm by wut
sorry double post
#28 - On 04/19/2009 at 8:28pm by wut
You don't really deserve this, he should've mentioned his choking daughter.. and I really doubt water is going to help his choking daughter anyway..
If I were the father, chances are I wouldn't have said or heard anything that wasn't going to help my daughter. He was probably going nuts or in shock, the poster probably shouldn't have said anything, but the dad probably shouldn't be blamed for anything beyond being a scarred and confused dad.
Internal attribution error.
Also, to anyone who suggested he should have mentioned his choking daughter... You're kind of a moron. If someone rushes somewhere and frantically demands something, you expect it to be understood that it's urgent, regardless of whether or not you explain it.
She probably had something that got partially stuck in her airway. Water can help dislodge it sometimes. Only ever happened to me once, though.
#30: Probably? He definitely shouldn't be blamed for doing his best to help his daughter.
you're mean!
#33 - On 04/19/2009 at 8:43pm by sayno
The guy was going to jab a needle through her chest into her lungs and fill her lungs with water till it forced the object out.
#34 - On 04/19/2009 at 8:44pm by ms31
#31, I seriously doubt the girl was in danger of dying. If she was, the dad would possibly be screaming for help, which we know he didn't do because then the poster would have heard the commotion. And who doesn't bring a couple bottles of water to the beach?
Wow, in any case, he just cut in front of you for water - not a big deal. You made a complete ass of yourself for sure. Get off your high horse and next time try to contain your self-righteous speeches.
way to go you jerk. ur lucky i don't do my voodoo on you..
Does this contest happen to be in Port Aransas in Texas? I was there Saturday afternoon...
And btw, I wouldn't feel too bad.
Wow, since Number 1 resisted it so well, I'll say it for them.
#1 (Quote from their mind)
"Woo-Hoo, I'm first!!! Yahooooooooo. O yeah!!! Numero Uno!!! Oh Snap Who's first? Me That's Who!!!", lol
#39 - On 04/19/2009 at 9:13pm by Lester
maybe the girl just has something stuck in her throat and not literally choking you dumb mother fuckers
She prolly wasn't actually choking. She may have been coughing on something perhaps and was close to it. Water does help before she gets to the point of actually chocking and the Heimlich Maneuver is needed.
First off, if some one cuts in line just for water and sounds urgent, let it be. It doesn't take that long to get that glass of water and it's prolly for something important. No need to yell at them and be bitchy. You were the only jackass there.
Second, why wasn't he yelling and screaming his daughter was choking? It's gonna be an either or thing. He'll be in panic and screaming to the world what's happening to his daughter, or he's in shock--making him pretty much mute and only focused on one thing: helping his daughter.
I don't really have a third, but did those few seconds REALLY kill you? I mean, srsly. Get over urself. And stop calling other ppl jackass'. It's not nice =)
Even if his daughter wasn't choking and he chugged that water or used it for something else. It doesn't matter. It just isn't nice.

Today, I went to the beach with my daughter. We got hot dogs and while she was eating, she started choking. I panicked and ran to the hot dog stand to get some water. I had to cut in front of some people and now everyone on the beach thinks im a jackass. FML
I'm amazed #41 is the first to wonder about the "us" in this FML. It's the first thing I thought when I read this.
You probably did deserve that for being impatient..
if someone runs up and demands a cup of water, it's clearly for a good reason
if they just cut in front and casually asked for a hotdog then I would see why you were mad.
Try to be a little more patient next time, maybe you're the one giving "us" a bad reputation.
#41 and #44
he just meant "people at the beach" when he said "us"
i bet it's already been said, but you NEVER give a choking person water. so not only is he a "jackass" but an idiot as well.
And this is why we bring water bottles instead of buying a coke!
But I do agree that you are an ass for being so close-minded.
...YDI...
be aware of your surroundings...
#14, water clears the the throat, just incase you didn't know.
It's not always clearly obvious that someone cutting you in line is there for a good reason. For all we know the man may not have done anything "frantic" as you're all assuming. All the OP stated was the he demanded a cup of water, which if it's as he says, sounds rather rude. Of course we all know in hindsight that he had "good reason?" to (not sure if it's a good idea to give a choking person water...). I'm sure most people would construe that as rude behavior if they were in his place, it's just that not all of us call someone a jackass even if we think they are. I know I wouldn't, but I don't blame the guy for having that kind of personality.
It's not like you knew that's what he wanted it for. I'm surprised water popped into his mind before the Heimlich!
If my child was choaking i would of said excuse me first and yelled "HELP I NEED WATER MY DAUGHTER IS CHOAKING" not..."I need water!"
It's not your fault you didnt know =-[
But you didnt have to call him a jack ass, i would of just looked at him like he was stupid
and just for some other comments i was breifly reading. people cut in line all the time it happens at schools and resturants on the side walks anywhere. so just because he cut in the line doesnt mean it was for a good reason.
GIVING HIS DAUGHTER WATER WHEN SHE IS CHOKING IS EFFING DUMB TO BEGIN WITH
PEOPLE ARE SO EFFING STUPID
Man you are my hero, I hate people in cut in line. It sucks though that it was for a real emergency.
He gave his choking daughter water , some people really don't need to be parents.
#58 - On 04/19/2009 at 11:31pm by JBiz
What the fuck happened to this website, all the top FMLs are clearly fakes...
#59 - On 04/19/2009 at 11:32pm by Broc
Wow, I'm really tired and I read that last sentence as...I then see him running to choke his daughter.
Heh, both a YDI and a FYL. Because the father was obviously stupid (bringing water to her choking daughter, demanding a glass of water instead of quickly explaining what was happening) and because, well, you should have been more polite yourself lol.
But then again, line-breakers piss me off too
@59- Then go away .
#62 - On 04/20/2009 at 12:14am by JBiz
haha something like this happened to my friend. he desperately needed napkins because he stabbed his own hand and was bleeding everywhere, so he cut the guy in front of him. he was then accused of stealing whatever the guy he cut was buying (shoes, i think). and this all happened in a country where he didn't speak the language.
what? how did they deserve it?
you didn't know that the girl was choking. that's not your fault. i would have been frustrated too if someone cut in front of me like that.
but yeah, this guy doesn't sound too smart. when someone is choking, you perform the heimlich maneuver. you may want to get the choking victim water AFTER the object has been projected out, but not during the choke attack...
i dont like cutters either...and she probably wasnt choking if she needed water
#65 - On 04/20/2009 at 12:36am by slamdnkindrummer
Who the hell is "us" in this FML?
9, so judge that everyone has a good reason for everything they do?
FYL- i probably wouldn't have said anything just because i always keep my mouth shut, but i would've felt shitty after that too.
why would you give water to a choking person?
The dad is retarded. Shouldn't he go to the lifeguard on duty?
Maybe his daughter was choked on the hotdog you were about to buy. He saved your life.
#60 LOL XD
#62 agreed, theyre the ones annoying me..
That Dad IS a jackass
mostly for not packing water in the first place
Y would u go to the beach without water???
#72 - On 04/20/2009 at 2:26am by scateice
How can someone know that the father is in such a great need?
Not your fault. The dumbass thinks he can save a life with water? What's he trying to do? DROWN her?
#11 ur fxxking funny xDDDDDD
#75 - On 04/20/2009 at 6:46am by iBou
people, this person didnt deserve this, they had no way of knowing that someone was choking, they assumed the guy was an asshole, as you all know you would given the situation, lay off. and yeah, water for someone choking? the hell?
my friend has a trampolene i fell getting off
you did NOT deserve that one
#78 - On 04/20/2009 at 9:26am by 1Tsk
how does water help a choking kid? and he could say excuse me, or give an explanation for his cutting...
Who's "US" in this description? Do you mean "homosexuals"? If so... then why did he have a daughter? Adopted?
Side question: So how were the hot dogs? I ain't gonna lie. that sounds fucking delicious to me right now.. A couple Chicago-style hotdogs.. with everything.. Mmmm...
If I've learned one thing in my life, it's that, if someone frantically asks for water, there must be something wrong.
Ok, everybody needs to shut up. Obviously, being the observer, what the OP saw probably wasn't choking but just heavy coughing.
That + people should not have to wait in a long line if all they want is a cup of water since 1) it's usually free and 2) takes 2 seconds to get.
So someone cut in front of you for something that takes five seconds to get on a slow day. Bad form when their daughter isn't choking, but you really had to make a scene about how YOU'RE RUINING IT FOR THE REST OF US? Grow up kthx.
youre quick to judge
#85 - On 04/20/2009 at 5:26pm by xij3ss
I've read some of the comments here. What the hell happened to being "respectful"?
Seriously. What the f*ck? Am I the only one that read "Our Rules"?
Besides, you don't EVER give a choking person food or water.
I would have done the same thing.
Besides, you don't ever give someone who is choking something to drink. It's common sense.
Obviously she wasn't really choking if that's all he did.
Probably was just having a coughing fit.
wow... someone cutting in front of you in line is not in need of a bitch attack.
if he like shoved you and you fell, and then he took your hot dog; then yeah.
#88 - On 04/20/2009 at 7:08pm by reetah
agree with #1
why would u give water to someone choking
#42, stupidest comment out of this whole thing. Go cut yourself. Of course, the girl is coughing on something and she needs water. I don't remember COUGHING and CHOKING was the same fucking thing. I think you're the biggest jackass out of this whole post. And guess what? I'M NOT NICE EITHER! IT'S LIFE BITCH, SUCK IT!
anyone who says the poster is mean/deserved this, you are stupid. if someone cut you in line you'd bitch too. NOBODY likes cutters.
Wow.
So turns out you're the jackass.
Oh common' guys, enough with the holier than thou attitudes. I am sure most of you would have been pissed off too if someone just rushed in front of you in a line. The point is she didn't notice the kid coughing at first, and why should she? Is she supposed to monitor everyone around her too? I have a feeling that most of you are full of it. BTW, admitting that she screwed up means she feels somewhat bad about it.
fuck the choking daughter, too bad for her
I dont think the Heimlich maneuver is safe for a kid, and you dont know what degree of "choking it is" I mean, havent ANY of you drank water when something went down the wrong pipe?
the "Heimlich Maneuver" is safe for anyone but you're not allowed to call it that anymore. now its just Abdominal Thrusts because people would sue Dr. Heimlich when it didn't work.
shoulda kept ur mouth shut buddy.
learn to keep comments to urself.
Everyone who is telling her to have thought it through is a dumbass, everyone says things like that on impulse.
he should have said something like 'My daughter is choking, I need a glass of water'.
Ouch bad luck hope you apoligized after
...choking, huh? Water doesn't help.
In fact I think it makes it worse. Totally not your fault, dood.
I still want to know who "us" is
not your fault; there are a lot of rude people these days, I would have assumed that the man was cutting as well
people that calls the author a jackass or mean are IDIOTS!! if someone cuts in front of you what should you smile about it no! who cares if water takes two seconds point is a random person just cuts in front of you then you call the person a name then after you see why he did it then u feel bad point blank!
Exactly! First of all if your child was choking im pretty sure u would be in too much of a panic to worry about cutting in line! It was an emergency even tho the guy wasn't going about it the right way but you still shouldn't jump on him swearing at the man. It's a line for food and it took two damn seconds so next time if you say anything it might be a little more respectable!
fyl? what about the mans daughter
Add a comment
Top of the page
You must have an FML account to comment.
Don't have an FML account yet ? Sign up to FML!