Paper back writer
Today, I got back a paper after a peer review. I had worked really hard on it over the last week and was proud of the end result. When I got the paper back, the only positive comment on the paper was, "Well, I really like the blue staple you used to hold it together." FML
Top comments
may_cause_fail 0
Colored staples are awesome. However, as long as whoever it was left constructive criticism, then you really have nothing to complain about. It can be hard to see something that you spent a lot of time on be unpopular, there are worse things. Not really an FML.
treasa 0
When I peer edit papers, I only pay attention to the things that are wrong. The purpose is to find places to make improvements. It isn't the editor's job to point out things you did well; that takes more of his or her time.
Add a comment · Reply to
You must be logged in to be able to post comments!
Comments (83)
alice192823 24
I don't think that most people on here realise this is a degree/Masters/PhD+ level paper being reviewed, and not just a class essay which the teacher makes you write a comment on.