Maybe it reminds him of something... Are you his first (human) girlfriend?

On the one hand, I can understand him complaining. On the other... it's not so easy to control your "music of the night", and he should be prepared to cope if needed.

I hope he didn't meant that squeaky screaming chicken toy.

... Try changing to "bwaa-haaa" noises instead... (or maybe wear a clown mask ... :)

Now you should buy a squeaky toy so next time you can mess with him

Well, moaning like a fucktard **** star will eventually creep any guy or woman out. If you moan like that because you don't like it then quit and tell him you don't like it. Moan like a normal woman. Shit!

Maybe he was a jerk about how he told you, it's hard to read that sort of thing from just an FML. But it's a good thing he communicated the issue to you. That's important stuff, communication.

Tell him you'll check out Groupon or seek out a tutor to correct the problem...or...just make nice, get on your knees, and tell him his member should stifle the squeak.

You can do better

a lot of inflatables have that issue. it's bit your fault. it's a defect in your new funbags.