Either way she would have been upset... if you bought her a small she would have been pissed because she couldn't have fit into it! FYL OP.

Agreed, a small wouldn't have fit her, but now she crushed because she's apparently gain a bunch of weight.... which is worse? Ehh, op's screwed either way, she's too insecure. Next time buy her jewelry or something like that, just not candy... that would be a new issue.

I still don't know why most girls/women bitch about being "fat" because they're not a size 0 or 1.. makes no sense. FYL

u need to get a new gf. sounds a lil high maintenance.

it's all about the curvy chicks anyway

its okay OP was being honest while she's in denial about her weight..... hopefully she can see the truth now

because number 51, for some reason, women think guys like girls who are a size 0... truth is most guys think the opposite. I mean a size 6-14 is still effing drop dead sexy.

medium is not big at all. it's healthy. curvy chicks FTW! but not fat ones. haha

Yup!

she must live in egypt 'cause she's in de-nile

I see what you did there 176! you sly boots (:

maybe op should stick to jewelry...

well... there is always the receipt ... if she don't like she can go to the store and exchange it ... so you aren't really effed but dude ... next time go for the earrings or other jewelery

Shit happens during that time of the month.

That actually wouldn't work. She'd still be upset cuz he thinks she's bigger than she really is.

That sentence is an oxymoron. Women do NOT have logic!

I know, eh? I don't understand girls, even though I am one. On another note, I'm an XL, and I wouldn't be mad at my boyfriend for giving me a dress my size.

Dude, I'm a girl and I don't even get it.

exactly. what? a medium isn't even that big. (ps girl)

Wow. you are a dick.

that made me laugh.

my hero

you sir, must not have a gf

What the hell is wrong with you?

exactly ^ So Stupid! just because you're not a skeleton doesn't mean you're fat!

I hate being really skinny, I wish I was fatter. How often do yo hear that? We all want what we don't have...

grass is always greener on the other side :P

I agree with dragonair..i, wish I was thicker :/

I'm a medium and I'm perfectly fine with my size :)

I don't think 82 needs to be any thicker but every guy likes something on the chicks bones (there is a fine line between something on em and "eww fat chicks")

107, you're an asshole. I don't go around calling people on here that often, but you really are a dick.

I wear medium too, what's wrong with it? I have a lot of muscle and I wouldn't fit into small just because of it so medium = / = fat.

Ronaldo sux

so true ........ MessiFTW

sooo? no one cares

I do the same! I mean, form fitting close are nice to go out in but I don't feel the need to wear something skin tight on a day to day basis.

I don't think that domestic abuse is the answer for anything at all let alone for someone being shallow.

Same with me and agreeed

exactly

I think it sucks to be a small, because they hardly ever have anything good in that size.

you realize how ignorant you sound to the rest of the female population? NOT ALL WOMEN ARE LIKE THAT, only the needy and ungrateful ones!

Your right he does sound ignorant. A women is actually right for once, does anybody know what this means? SHES A WITCH! Listen mister, WOMEN HAVE NO LOGIC!!!!!