By LukeSkywalker - 23/12/2011 16:38 - United States

Today, after pouring my heart out to my girlfriend of 4 years through a speech that took me 3 weeks to write, and then proposing, she responded, "Eh, why not." FML
I agree, your life sucks 38 277
You deserved it 4 655

Same thing different taste

Top comments

natashax21 5

Take that as a yes and marry her before she has time to reconsider.


exactly. dont ever expect too much out of females

^ wow you're gonna get 100 thumbs down for that comment

Nyah, im pretty sure guys will even that out

asoptavlo14 6

Ooo I sense some gender tension about to start..

jwade11 12

Males are just as bad and unreliable as females. Sexist bastards. ;-)

bugmenotmofo 34

#7- I don't sense you having a girlfriend in the near future.

"Girlfriend, do you take this man to be your lawfully wedded husband, to love and cherish him? In sickness and in health? For better or for worse? Until death do you part?" "I do." OP, Do you take this woman to be your lawfully wedded wife, to love and cherish her? In sickness and in health? For better or for worse? Until death do you part?" "Eh, why not."

perhaps the quarter of a carat diamond was too small for the "HELLZ YEAH!" he was expecting

Luke Skywalker should stick to fighting in galactic civil wars instead of writing speeches.

Blue ghost Vader: NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!! Luke, go back to figting galactic civil wars instead of writing speeches, THEN WE'LL RULE THE GALAXY AS FATHER AND SON!!!!

I think that's better than a no. *forever alone*

At least girls don't have to ask guys... how embarrassing.

chlorinegreen 27

71 honestly it shouldn't matter about the ring or the diamond size. If you love someone none of the superficial things matter. OP take a hint by her response. do you want to settle for a eh why not?

7- are you ******* crazy? You sound insane right now.

desireev 17

84- I think it is so sweet when a girl proposes to a guy. And it's a million times sweeter to see him say "yes" with confidence and love behind it. It wouldn't be embarrassing. Guy-proposes-to-girl is another one of those things that a man "should have to do". I don't think so. If a woman wants to propose to a man, more power to her!

bizarre_ftw 21

107 - then again, some girls just like the fact that they can hide behind the social standard and wait for the guy to make the first move. Not saying it's a good idea, just pointing it out

hellbilly205 17

Id rather get an "ehh, why not" then a no anyday, on a side note congrats, on taking the plunge hope your marrige lasts a long time!

tjv3 10

You might regret later if you dont consider breaking up when you have time.... She doesnt seem to be interested.. :(

lil_miss_katii 7

at least she said yes, it could have been a lot worse

blunttobluntest 12

Let's hope it is a happily ever after and NOT just a long time.

Minx108 12

I agree 159! The enthusiasm you have for one another seems a bit disproportionate...if you're going to get married you'd want to be equally enthralled with each other, wouldn't you?

I agree 159.... It might as we'll be a no.. Doesn't sound like she's all that stoked.

All people doesn't see the value of marriage. I wouldn't mind getting married, but i dob't think it's such a big deal.

fjretsel 1

At least she said yes u prick.

Well, she's um....not really that emotional

natashax21 5

Take that as a yes and marry her before she has time to reconsider.

Mabye getting a pre-nup wouldn't be a bad idea. You know what's hers is hers and whats your's is your's... Unless she makes more than you, then don't do it

WaterPoloLove3 0

Good idea, you never know, she could just be like... Well I haven't wandered down this path yet, let's see where it takes me(:

lol, so they can be in a dead end marriage for the rest of there lives... that is, until the divorce. lmao.

Caitlyn2 0

Atleast you're getting married and that she said yes.

JustinThunder 8

Actually, I believe she said, "Eh, why not?"

Im Canadian.. But hey, Thats pretty funny. xDD

Llama_Face89 33

127- Hey! I'm Canadian! If I wasnt a pacifist I'd **** you up! :P

@157 lol Canada only there to go skiing :)

Like when canada went on strike for more money but instead we gave them bennigans coupons and bubble gum

Knowing my own standard answer to everything my bf proposes (e.g. what to eat for dinner), I'd probably go 'Sure.'

HogwartsDropout7 0

That's when you tell her that you changed your mind.

NotsoobviousTrol 5

Should have given her bacon first

BrownEyes97 1

That generally only works on guys.

no, it works for girls too. trust me. especially younger ones. *trollface*

OhLohd111 11

What if she's Jewish? Kosher bacon, bitches. lmao.

YESSS! Bacon strips and bacon strips and back strips!!!!

natashax21 5
Rainchikmoo 6
gene818 13

It only works on the weak minds.

Eh, at least you tried. Sorry OP. hopefully she was just joking around with you.